Our Family of Companies
western & southern financial group
western & southern life
columbus life insurance company
eagle realty group
fort washington investment advisors
gerber life insurance
integrity life insurance company
lafayette life insurance company
national integrity life insurance company
touchstone investments
western & southern financial group distributors

Navigating the 2020 Stretch Run & Looming Policy Changes

By Nick Sargen
Markets Policy
Share:
Winding road
  • The U.S. economy has made rapid progress recovering from business shutdowns owing to an unprecedented fiscal and monetary response.  However, the COVID-19 pandemic is not under control as evinced by the shocking news about President Trump.  
  • Going forward, it is unclear whether new legislation will be passed to replace provisions in the CARES Act that have expired. But one thing is clear: The Federal Reserve will keep interest rates close to zero for the foreseeable future.
  • The November elections could lead to significant policy changes if there is a “blue wave.” Biden’s fiscal plan calls for added government spending that would be financed by higher taxes on corporations and households earning more than $400,000.
  • If so, the stock market could sell off if investors harvest capital gains before taxes are raised. However, any sell-off could be short-lived as investors assess the prospects for future growth.

U.S. Stock Market Powers Ahead

The U.S. stock market rally since late March has been among the most powerful in history and continued unabated until September, when it experienced a correction of about 10% (Figure 1). Even then, the S&P 500 Index at the end of September was up by 45% from the March lows while the tech-heavy Nasdaq Index rose even more at 60%.

Figure 1: 2020 Investment Returns by Asset Class (in percent)
Stock Market Q1 Q2 Q3
U.S. (S&P 500)  -19.6  20.5 8.9
Russell 20001 -30.6 25.4 4.9
International (EAFE $) -22.7 15.1 4.9
Emerging Markets (MSCI $) -23.6 18.1 9.7
Source: Bloomberg. Past performance is not indicative of future results. You cannot invest directly in an index. For informational purposes only.
U.S. Bond Market Q1 Q2 Q3
Treasuries 8.2 0.5 0.2
IG Credit -3.1 8.2 1.5
High Yield -12.7 10.2 4.6

The stock market’s performance mirrors the path of the U.S. economy.  When the coronavirus pandemic hit in March, it necessitated widespread shutdowns of businesses that many economists warned would result in a severe recession. This was confirmed in the second quarter when the economy experienced the steepest quarterly decline in post war history, with real GDP contracting by 33% at an annual rate.

An unprecedented policy response that included nearly $4 trillion in federal support and the Federal Reserve expanding its playbook from the 2008 financial crisis helped to contain the fallout. These actions and the reopening of businesses generated a strong rebound in the third quarter: Estimates of annualized real GDP growth are in the vicinity of 25%-35%.

According to Jim Glassman of JPMorgan Chase, roughly 85% of final demand has returned to pre-crisis levels, and the level of real GDP is back to 97-98% of the February level.2  Moreover, consumer spending is back to pre-crisis levels due to massive transfer payments from the federal government.  Viewed from this perspective, what happened to the economy is analogous to a hurricane that created widespread destruction, but which also set the stage for a powerful revival.

The Economy Is Not Out of the Woods

The key difference from the hurricane analogy is the incidence of COVID-19 has not slowed. When the CARES Act was enacted in late March, policymakers believed the worst would be over by summer.  Accordingly, key features of the bill, including the provision for an added unemployment compensation of $600 per week, expired at the end of July.

In the meantime, the U.S. unemployment rate, which peaked at 14.7% in April, has fallen to 7.9% in September, as many furloughed workers have returned to their jobs. There has also been a significant reallocation of labor from dying businesses to up-and-coming ones. 

However, significant layoffs have continued as evinced by high weekly jobless claims (Figure 2). Furthermore, a wave of new layoffs from airlines and several major corporations have been announced recently. Meanwhile, the number of those permanently unemployed has increased to 3.8 million in September from 2 million in April.

Weekly US Job Claims

Congress currently is debating whether to pass another round of fiscal stimulus to address this problem. Until recently, there was a wide gap between Congressional Democrats and Republicans over the size of a package. However, the gap has narrowed as Democrats recrafted a $2.2 trillion package while the White House upped its offer closer to $1.6 trillion. Following President Trump’s return from Walter Reed Army Medical Center to the White House, he has sent conflicting messages about his stance on providing added assistance before the election.


Looking ahead, the big unknown is whether a second wave of COVID-19 will hit in fall and winter, which could slow the pace of recovery. There already has been a spike in cases since the Labor Day weekend. It has delayed school openings in some states, and the pace of recovery slowed in September. Amid all of this, the U.S. stock market experienced a correction of about 10% during the month. 

Fed to the Rescue 

The issue investors now face is whether the pull-back represents a buying opportunity or is the harbinger of more to come. The most likely outcome in our view is the stock market may stay range bound through year’s end.

The main factor limiting the market’s upside is favorable news already is priced into the market. First, valuations as measured by one year forward P/E multiples are high. Second, Wall Street analysts are calling for a significant recovery in S&P 500 profits in the coming year.  

The principal factor supporting the market is interest rates are likely to remain close to zero for the foreseeable future. The Federal Reserve recently announced that it will now target an average rate of inflation of 2% over a business cycle. Consequently, if inflation undershoots the target in a year, it will be allowed to overshoot it in subsequent years. Moreover, the Fed will no longer raise interest rates preemptively if unemployment is low. Accordingly, the Fed has been proactive in lessening downside risks for the economy and the stock market.
 

Impact of the November Elections

Meanwhile, investors will turn their attention to the upcoming elections. While polls show Joe Biden maintaining a significant lead over President Trump nationally and a fair chance the Democrats could win the Senate, the election has not been a major driver of the stock market thus far. One reason is investors are mindful of the surprise results in 2016 and are inclined to await the actual results. 

One of the biggest differences from the policies of the Trump administration is Biden’s fiscal plan. It is estimated by the Penn Wharton Budget Model (PWBM) to increase federal spending by $5.4 trillion over the next ten years.3 If enacted, it would increase federal spending to 24% of GDP by 2030 from 21% in 2019.

To help finance the increased federal spending, Biden would roll back the Tax Cut and Jobs Act (TCJA) enacted in December 2017. The corporate tax rate would be increased to 28% from 21% while the rate on foreign profits would be increased and a minimum tax on corporate book income would be imposed. 

On the personal side, households with adjusted gross income (AGI) of $400,000 or less would not see their taxes increase directly. Those above this threshold (the top 1.5 percent of households) would face an average decrease in after-tax income of 17.7%. 

In these circumstances, increased government spending is unlikely to generate substantially higher Treasury bond yields. However, the stock market could sell-off if Biden wins and individuals opt to sell stocks and pay capital gains taxes before higher taxes are imposed.

Over the long term, however, the main consideration for investors is whether Biden would be beholden to liberal Democrats such as Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren. The fiscal plan Biden has put forth suggests otherwise, as the scope of federal spending and tax changes is less extreme. Furthermore, the assessment of the PWBM, Moody’s Analytics, and economists at Goldman Sachs is the Biden plan could boost growth in the future. If so, any stock market sell-off could be short lived. 


1 Frank Russell Company (FRC) is the source and owner of the Russell Index data contained or reflected in this material and all trademarks and copyrights related thereto. The presentation may contain confidential information pertaining to FRC and unauthorized use, disclosure, copying, dissemination or redistribution is strictly prohibited. This is a FWIA presentation of the Russell Index data.  Frank Russell Company is not responsible for the formatting or configuration of this material or for any inaccuracy in FWIA’s presentation thereof. 
2  Weekly Insights on the Markets & the Economy, September 28, 2020.
3 PWBM Analysis of the Biden Plan, September 14, 2020.

nick sargen

Nick Sargen

Senior Economic Advisor
Nick is an international economist, global money manager, author, and contributor on television business news programs. He earned a PhD and MA from Stanford University and BA from UC, Berkeley.

Related Insights