Insurance products evolve and so do your needs. If your life insurance or annuity no longer aligns with your goals, you may be wondering how to upgrade without paying taxes on gains. That’s where a 1035 exchange comes in.
A 1035 exchange lets you transfer funds from one insurance contract to another - life insurance, annuity, or endowment - without triggering immediate taxation. It’s a smart, IRS-approved way to move your money more efficiently within your financial strategy.
What Is a 1035 Exchange?
A 1035 exchange is a like-kind exchange between insurance products under Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code.1 It allows you to transfer assets directly from one policy to another, without cashing out.
If you simply surrender your existing policy and buy a new one, you may owe taxes on any investment gains. But a properly executed 1035 exchange defers that taxation, keeping more of your money working for you.
Eligible Transfers
| From | To | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Life Insurance | Life Insurance | Allows an exchange to a new policy with different features or lower costs. |
| Life Insurance | Annuity or Endowment Contract | Often used when shifting from protection to income or investment purposes. |
| Endowment Contract | Annuity | Permitted under Section 1035 for continued tax deferral. |
| Annuity | Another Annuity | Common for upgrading to a product with better benefits, riders, or lower fees. |
Note: You cannot move from an annuity contract back into a life insurance policy under Section 1035 rules.
How a 1035 Exchange Works
A 1035 exchange may sound technical, but the process is fairly straightforward once you understand the steps. It allows you to switch insurance or annuity contracts smoothly without a taxable event. Here’s how it typically unfolds:
- Review your current policy. Start by taking a close look at your existing contract. Assess the death benefit, cash value, fees, and potential surrender charges for early withdrawals. Check whether if your policy aligns with your investment goals or falls short due to high costs or limited options.
- Compare new policy options. Consider a fixed annuity with guaranteed income, a variable annuity with market participation, or a life policy with modern riders like long-term care or chronic illness coverage, which is a chance to upgrade to something that better fits your needs today.
- Request 1035 exchange paperwork. Once you choose the new policy, your insurance company will provide the forms to begin the transfer. These forms authorize the direct movement of funds between the old and new insurance companies - no checks are sent to you. This step is key to maintaining the tax benefits outlined under IRC Section 1035.
- Verify ownership and insured details. For the exchange to qualify as tax-free, the owner and insured (or annuitant) must be identical across both contracts. If ownership changes, it can disqualify the transaction, making it taxable. This rule helps the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) confirm the transaction remains a true “like-kind” exchange.
- Wait for processing and confirmation. Transfers may take weeks, with funds moving directly between insurers, preserving your premium basis. Once complete, the new policy or annuity is active maintaining your accumulated value tax-free.
- Keep documentation for your records. Always retain written confirmation of the transaction, including the 1035 paperwork and any correspondence from both insurers. These documents serve as proof that the transfer met IRS guidelines if questions arise later.
Why Consider a 1035 Exchange?
A 1035 exchange allows you to upgrade an old insurance or annuity contract to a more suitable one without immediate tax on gains. Many choose this option to better match their financial products to evolving goals, lifestyles, or market conditions. Here’s why it may make sense:
- Lower fees and expenses: Older life insurance and annuity contracts often carry higher administrative costs, mortality charges, or management fees. A newer policy might offer improved cost structures and more transparent pricing, helping you retain more of your investment gains over time.
- Improved guarantees and benefits: Advances in insurance design mean many newer contracts offer stronger death benefits or enhanced living benefits. For example, some policies now include built-in minimum income guarantees or market-protection features that weren’t available a decade ago.
- Updated investment options: A variable annuity contract or income annuity may provide access to more diversified or lower-cost subaccounts, better risk-adjusted returns, or improved reallocation flexibility. This can be especially helpful if your investment goals have evolved from accumulation to income generation or principal preservation.
- Better alignment with your financial goals: As your priorities shift - maybe from wealth building to securing reliable retirement income - your current policy may not offer the flexibility you need. A 1035 exchange helps you transition to a product that supports your updated objectives, whether that’s guaranteed lifetime income or a more tailored mix of protection and growth potential.
- Enhanced riders and policy features: Many modern insurance contracts include optional riders for long-term care, chronic illness, or income acceleration, giving you added protection for life events that could affect your finances. Older policies might lack these features entirely or require additional underwriting to add them.
- Improved company strength or ratings: Sometimes, the motivation for a 1035 exchange isn’t about the policy itself but the provider. If your current insurer has merged, changed ownership, or experienced downgrades in financial ratings, transferring your policy to a stronger company may give you greater confidence in the long term.
Pros & Cons of a 1035 Exchange
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Tax-deferred transfer under IRC Section 1035 | Potential surrender charges on the old policy |
| Upgrade to better policy or variable annuity contract | New policy may have a new surrender period |
| Avoids immediate tax on investment gains | Possible loss of original death benefit features |
| Opportunity to align with new investment goals | May require a new medical exam or higher premiums |
| Can consolidate multiple insurance contracts | Outstanding loans could disqualify the exchange |
Partial 1035 Exchanges: Flexibility Without Full Commitment
A partial 1035 exchange lets you transfer a portion of your policy's cash value to a new, maintaining current benefits while exploring new options. It's ideal for testing new features or investments without fully replacing your existing insurance.
Benefits of Partial 1035 Exchanges
- Retain valuable benefits: While common for annuities, partial 1035 exchanges are rarely permitted for life insurance. For annuities, a partial exchange allows you to move a portion of funds to a new contract while keeping the remainder in the existing one.
- Test new opportunities: Transfer some funds into a different variable annuity or fixed annuity to explore better performance or new product features.
- Avoid full surrender charges: Moving only a portion of your cash value helps reduce potential surrender charges from your existing policy.
- Manage tax exposure carefully: By staying within Section 1035 guidelines, you can preserve tax benefits and defer gains on the transferred portion.
- Maintain flexibility: If the new product performs well, you can later transfer more of your remaining balance or stay diversified across contracts.
Partial 1035 exchanges require careful management. The IRS monitors these transactions closely, particularly when funds are withdrawn soon after the exchange. Under the current safe harbor standard, if a withdrawal occurs within 180 days of a partial exchange, the IRS may classify the transaction as a taxable distribution rather than a qualified exchange.
Key Tax Considerations
The goal of any 1035 exchange, whether full or partial, is to defer taxes and preserve your policy’s value. To accomplish that, you need to follow the rules carefully.
- Tax deferral: A properly executed Section 1035 exchange is not considered a taxable event. You’re simply moving your money from one insurance contract to another.
- Basis preservation: Your cost basis (the total premiums you’ve paid) transfers to the new policy or annuity contract, ensuring any future taxes are calculated correctly.
- Outstanding loans: If your existing contract has loans, the amount may be considered taxable if it’s not repaid or carried over correctly.
- Ownership and insured requirements: Both policies must have the same owner and insured (or annuitant). Any change can disqualify the transaction from tax-free treatment.
- Non-qualified annuities only: Qualified plans (like 401(k)s or IRAs) follow different tax rules and cannot be transferred via a 1035 exchange. Only non-qualified annuities qualify under these provisions.
- Timing matters: Refrain from making withdrawals or taking from either the original or the new contract shortly after you have finalized the 1035 exchange. Doing so might lead the IRS to consider it as an indirect taxable distribution.
When a 1035 Exchange Might Not Be Right
While 1035 exchanges offer flexibility and tax advantages, they’re not right for everyone. Sometimes, staying with your current policy - or making internal adjustments - is the smarter move. Consider avoiding one if:
- Surrender charges: If your current contract is still within its designated surrender period, opting to transfer it at this time might in incurring a cost that takes away a percentage of your total account value.
- Lost guarantees: Some variable annuity contracts and older life insurance policies include benefits that can’t be replicated - such as guaranteed minimum income or high death benefit locks.
- Health or age changes: If your health has deteriorated since you initially bought your original policy, obtaining a new life insurance policy be costlier, and it may also pose more challenges in terms of qualifying for coverage.
- Resetting the clock: Entering into a new insurance or annuity contract typically initiates a fresh surrender period, which generally impos new limitations on when and how you can withdraw funds without incurring fees.
- Fees and complexity: Some modern annuities or insurance products have higher fees, complex riders, or variable market risk that may not suit conservative investors.
The Bottom Line
A 1035 exchange can be a smart, tax-efficient way to move between insurance contracts or annuity products. It lets policyholders pursue better features, lower costs, or stronger returns without triggering taxes. Be sure to review fees, surrender terms, and your overall plan before moving forward.
Boost your coverage with smart policy enhancements. Request a Free Life Insurance Quote
Sources
- Section 1035.--Certain Exchanges of Insurance Policies. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-03-51.pdf.
